Research

Audit of short term outcomes of surgical and medical second trimester termination of pregnancy

Annamarie Mauelshagen¹ , Lynn C Sadler^1,2 , Helen Roberts^1,2 , Mahesh Harilall² and Cynthia M Farquhar^1,2

¹  Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand

²  National Women's Health, Auckland District Health Board, Auckland, New Zealand

author email corresponding author email

Reproductive Health 2009, 6:16doi:10.1186/1742-4755-6-16

Published:	30 September 2009

Abstract

Background

As comparisons of modern medical and surgical second trimester termination of pregnancy (TOP) are limited, and the optimum method of termination is still debated, an audit of second trimester TOP was undertaken, with the objective of comparing the outcomes of modern medical and surgical methods.

Methods

All cases of medical and surgical TOP between the gestations of 13 and 20 weeks from 1st January 2007 to 30th June 2008, among women residing in the local health board district, a tertiary teaching hospital in an urban setting, were identified by a search of ICD-10 procedure codes (surgical terminations) and from a ward database (medical terminations). Retrospective review of case notes was undertaken. A total of 184 cases, 51 medical and 133 surgical TOP, were identified. Frequency data were compared using Chi-squared or Fischer's Exact tests as appropriate and continuous data are presented as mean and standard deviation if normally distributed or median and interquartile range if non-parametric.

Results

Eighty-one percent of surgical terminations occurred between 13 to 16 weeks gestation, while 74% of medical terminations were performed between 17 to 20 weeks gestation. The earlier surgical TOP occurred in younger women and were more often indicated for maternal mental health. Sixteen percent of medical TOP required surgical delivery of the placenta. Evacuation of retained products was required more often after medical TOP (10%) than after surgical TOP (1%). Other serious complications were rare.

Conclusion

Both medical and surgical TOP are safe and effective for second trimester termination. Medical TOP tend to be performed at later gestations and are associated with a greater likelihood of manual removal of the placenta and delayed return to theatre for retained products. This case series does not address long term complications.